top of page

Third-Party Studies and Job Multipliers: Fluff or Foundation?

AIIC
Oct 26
5 min read

Are third-party projections from firms like JLL and HVS reliable? Aaron Goforth, Phuong Le and Kevin Wright explain their role in job creation.



Featuring: Aaron Goforth, Phuong Le (KLDP) and Kevin Wright · From the AIIC Nov 19, 2025 webinar


Are third-party projections from firms like JLL or HVS reliable, or just fluff? Aaron Goforth and Phuong Le explained that independent feasibility work objectively supports the business model that drives job creation. It's "showing your work" instead of taking the developer's word. USCIS questions the inputs, not the formula, and a GMP contract plus a third-party study backs them up.


Doesn't I-526E approval already validate the multipliers? Kevin Wright explained that USCIS reviews model screenshots and whether the region is reasonable. Once the I-526E is approved, the multipliers are set. Third-party studies tend to nail total revenue, and if the revenue is right, the jobs are right.


Key takeaways

  • Independent feasibility studies support the model's inputs.

  • USCIS questions inputs, not the formula.

  • Once the I-526E is approved, the multipliers are set.


Watch more


Full transcript

Vikram Kumar: A lot of projects bring in firms like JLL or HVS for third-party projections. How often do those projections actually come to fruition? Are they generally a lot of fluff? Can you rely on these reports? Based on your experience and the outcomes you've seen across the projects you've structured, what's your take?

Phuong Le: I'm glad you asked that, because I've been waiting for a question I can give to Aaron, and this is the perfect one. Those things are important in terms of business plan credibility and backing up the economic reports. Aaron, can you talk about why feasibility reports, and third-party reports in general, are important, whether the finished product has to track them, and what their value really is?

Aaron Goforth: It's been said earlier in this webinar that job creation is often tied to the construction and operation of a project. So having a third party objectively look at the business model, the business dynamics in the area and the demand drivers, and give its blessing to the reasonableness of the project, is very important. Historically, hospitality has been very popular in EB-5, and I think it's for that very reason. It's a mature industry. The cost of construction is a known element, and there are a lot of very successful brokers and third-party companies that can verify the construction and development costs and also the ongoing operations. What demand drivers are in the market? What do the population and demographics look like? Does the business model warrant the revenue projections being forecast?

So generally, I do think every solid project should have a feasibility study. It's just the basics of supporting your business assumptions. And in the big picture, it's: does the deal make sense? As an observer or user of a hospitality product, or anything else, does it make sense? A feasibility study can be a good, objective third party to support that.

Phuong Le: So it's not really about whether the final product lines up exactly with the feasibility study. It's more of a credibility test. If someone says their budget or final numbers are going to look a certain way, it's a way to show your work for your forecast.

Aaron Goforth: That's a perfect way to say it. It's showing your work. It's not taking the developer's word that the budget and forecasts are reasonable. It's showing the work through an objective third party that uses quantifiable metrics to support the business model, which in turn supports the job creation.

Phuong Le: We've done projects for a number of years. It rarely happens now, because a lot of it can be preempted, but if USCIS questions your job creation forecast, it's never really the formula they're questioning. They're questioning whether the input numbers make sense. There are two ways to back that up. Number one, if you have a GMP contract from a general contractor, then they know it's going to be built for that amount. Or, for future revenues, a third-party feasibility report makes Aaron's work a lot easier. So for those of you wondering, that's the value a third-party report brings to the table.

Vikram Kumar: Doesn't the I-956F approval from USCIS further validate a lot of that data, like verifying your NAICS code multipliers and the methodology you've used? Isn't that part of the whole basis for getting the I-956F approved?

Kevin Wright: Yes. When it comes to job multipliers, they're going to review the economic analysis, and the economic analysis has to include direct screenshots from the economic model showing that you're not making the multipliers up or skewing them, that they came from the model itself. That's all going to be included. They're also going to review things like whether your region makes sense. Did you try to claim indirect jobs for the entire United States when your project is located in Minneapolis? Or did you limit your region to where most of the jobs are really going to be created, the Minneapolis-St. Paul area? They're going to verify those things and make sure they clearly make sense. And once the I-956F is approved, you know your multipliers are set in stone. They're not going to go back on them.

I'd also add that one thing I've noticed in projects over the years is that third-party studies generally get it right on total revenue projections. They tend to be pretty straight on. Where you sometimes fall short, or where things happen that they can't estimate, is cost. And the importance of this is that as long as you get the total revenue right, the jobs are going to be right, and they're going to be there. Where they sometimes miss is that they can't foresee that, two years after the projection, the government raised the minimum wage by 40%, for example. They can't always be accurate on cost, because they can't see the future. But they do tend to be pretty accurate on revenue projections, because they're using actual data from every competing project in the area. So it tends to be pretty close on that side.

This article and video share views from panelists in an AIIC webinar. They are for general information only and are not legal, tax, immigration or investment advice, or an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security. EB-5 investments involve risk, including the possible loss of capital.

Comments


bottom of page