top of page

Developer Skin in the Game: How Much Is Enough?

AIIC
Oct 14
4 min read

Cathy Holmes of JMBM explains how developer equity should be structured to protect EB-5 investors.



Featuring: Cathy Holmes (JMBM) · From the AIIC Jan 28, 2026 webinar


How should developer skin in the game be structured? Cathy Holmes wants the developer to hold at least 20% of common equity, so that the developer bears the first loss.

Land can count toward that equity at cost, or at an appreciated appraised value when a real appraisal supports it.


Key takeaways

  • Look for at least 20% developer common equity.

  • The developer should bear the first loss.

  • Land counts at cost, or at appraised value backed by a real appraisal.


Watch more


Full transcript


Vikram Kumar: Cathy, you were talking about the different elements. I know one thing we were going to talk about was what a capital stack looks like, and developer skin in the game. Can you talk a little about how you would structure, or how you've structured, good EB-5 projects with developer equity?

Cathy Holmes: Sure. The capital stack is the blocks of equity and the blocks of debt that stack up to cover the complete project cost. When I think of the PPM, I typically see the senior debt first. So I've got the senior loan, and then, if the EB-5 is a loan, either the EB-5 is in the senior position or, if it's in the mezzanine position, it's right below the senior loan. If there's any other debt, for example C-PACE, that will be in the capital stack too. Then you've got the equity side. You may see some common equity and you may see preferred equity.

The common equity is the first to lose money, because it's the lowest on the capital stack. What I would typically like to see is that the developer itself holds at least 20% of the common equity of the project. That means if somebody's going to lose money, it's the developer, and I want to see that they have a significant amount of money in the project, so that they're going to lose a significant amount if there's a loss. If you have a developer with 1% or 2%, some small amount of capital, they don't lose that much if the project fails. They walk away. Sure, they lose their money, but everybody else loses far more than they do, and you don't want that, because it misaligns the incentives. You want the developer to have a significant risk of loss in the project.

Vikram Kumar: Skin in the game: put their money where their mouth is. And how do you differentiate between types of equity? It could be an actual cash injection by the developer, or it could be land value. What do you look for in those cases?

Cathy Holmes: You want to look at both: what cash equity they have in the project, and what land value they have in the project. When it comes to land value, what you want to know is how much the developer actually paid for that property. Are they giving themselves credit for the appreciated value of the property, or just for its cost? If they've held the property for a while, it's fair to expect the developer to receive some credit for its appreciated value. If a bank were making a loan, it would typically give them credit for the appreciated value if that value is supported by an appraisal.

Vikram Kumar: That was going to be my question. You need an appraisal to demonstrate that value. If a developer buys land and gets it entitled and permitted, it could be appraised at a much higher value than what they paid.

Cathy Holmes: Yes, that's a perfect example. They shouldn't just be credited with the purchase price, because the property is now worth more than it was on the date they bought it. If they've received the entitlements and done pre-development work, the appraisal should show additional value as a result.

Vikram Kumar: Would a broker letter work, or do you need a formal appraisal?

Cathy Holmes: A broker letter is some evidence, but appraisals are usually much better, because a broker opinion of value isn't as detailed a report. Appraisals are required to meet very high standards. They have to look at comparable properties in the area and write up a full report on why they think the value has increased. Even then, there's no guarantee the property is worth exactly what the appraiser said. At the end of the day, a property is worth whatever you can sell it for. But at least it's evidence that someone spent a significant amount of time evaluating the current value of the property before giving the developer credit for any appreciated value.

This article and video share views from panelists in an AIIC webinar. They are for general information only and are not legal, tax, immigration or investment advice, or an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security. EB-5 investments involve risk, including the possible loss of capital.

Comments


bottom of page